(Previous discussion continued)
peer-reviewed journals Olga Ayoub 08 Nov 2006 13:38 UTC

peer-reviewed journals Olga Ayoub 08 Nov 2006 13:38 UTC

Are there any guides or listings of journals (other than in Ulrich's or
Cabell's) which will provide more details on which journal titles are
peer-reviewed, editorially-reviewed and blind or double-blind reviewed?

Thank you,

Olga Ayoub Mansour, B.A., M.L.I.S.


Serials Librarian

Jafet Library

American University of Beirut

P.O.Box 11-0236

Beirut, Lebanon

Tel. 961 (1) 374444 ext. 2608

Fax. 961 (1) 744703

-----Original Message-----
From: SERIALST: Serials in Libraries Discussion Forum
[mailto:SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU] On Behalf Of Helen Aiello
Sent: Friday, September 08, 2006 1:18 AM
Subject: Re: [SERIALST] Tiers and journals

In some cases tier pricing is based on your institution's Carnegie

Classification  Description <

http://www.carnegiefoundation.org/classifications/index.asp?key=785 >

or, in cases where there are usage stats for an online product/journal, by

the amount of usage an institution makes of the online resource being

priced, e.g AIP titles or Project Muse.

Who applies it?  Depending on the size of your institution and/or the

programs offered by your institution (the website above spells it out in

detail) either you apply it or the pricing agent/publisher.  If your

institution does not fall into a neat Tier, then you may have to have a

discussion with the agent/publisher applying the pricing.  Since Wesleyan

University is one of those institutions that falls between Tiers, I am

always having to make a case for appropriate Tier pricing.

Who manages it?  Depends on how much you trust your vendor to be able to

manage that information for your account. Two of the larger vendors with

whom I work can keep this info as part of our records in their data files.

Otherwise, its in your hands to assure the correct pricing has been

assigned for what you think is your Tier.

I am assuming that the above information relates to the Tier pricing you

are encountering.  But who knows: maybe some publisher thought up another

method that I have not yet come across.

Gotta love the creative economic models for serial pricing.  Certainly

keeps us on our toes to stay informed!


Helen M. Aiello, Serials/E-Resources Librarian

Wesleyan University, Middletown, CT  (A tier 2 or 3, depending on the good

graces of the pricing agency)


At 02:52 PM 9/7/2006, you wrote:

>Hello all,


>Can anyone point me to a document that will define the process by which

>journals are designated with a tier (i.e. tier one, tier two etc.)?  Or,

>could anyone please enlighten me about this ranking?  I am having a hard

>time finding any sort of concrete definition or explanation.  Is this a

>standard?  If so, who applies it and manages it?


>Thanks for any insight,




>Jane Binksma

>Acquisitions Librarian

>Collections Team

>Ryerson University Library

>350 Victoria Street

>Toronto, ON

>M5B 2K3

>416-979-5000 ex. 4855