Email list hosting service & mailing list manager


Re: JSTOR print backfiles Latchney, Jim 16 Feb 2007 17:16 UTC

I have to clarify that this list represents only a portion of the titles that were reviewed. It was my initial understanding that they were all to be reviewed but much of the decisions to discard or kept also related to space issues within our Main Library. Those titles stored in our Remote Storage facility have not and possibly will not be reviewed as they have little impact on current space considerations on campus. That said, I hope you all find this list useful for the titles it does cover and will help you make decisions about whether or not to keep selected titles.

(Leave = keep)

If for some reason the table doesn’t display properly, I’ll have the document changed into a PDF and will provide a URL to get to it.

Title

Years in J-STOR

Description

Decision

Imago Mundi

1935-2002

pictures & foldouts

leave

American Anthropologist

1888-1998

pictures & foldouts

leave

American Ethnologist

1974-1998

pictures

leave

Ethnohistory

1954-1999

pictures

leave

Ethos

1973-1998

2 pics in v. 14

remove

Medical Anthropology Quarterly

1983-1998

1 pic in v.2

remove

Cultural Anthropology

1986-1998

Pictures, 1995-2004 on the shelf

Leave

Journal of American Folklore

1888-2000

Pictures, 1926-2004 on the shelf

Leave

Western folklore

1947-2000

pictures

Leave

Dance Research

1983-2002

pictures

Leave

Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science

1890-2000

takes up 2 sections of shelf, so I sampled about every other book until I found pictures, found in 5 volumes (3 volumes have several)

Social Science History

1976-1999

remove

Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science

1910-1928, 1928-1991

1 foldout

remove

The Journal of Economic Education

1969-2000

remove

The American Statistician

1947-2000

pictures

Leave

The Canadian Journal of Economics

1968-2002

remove

Economica

1921-2000

4 foldouts

remove

Land Economics

1948-2003

remove

Oxford Economic Papers

1938-1997

couple of foldouts

remove

Journal of Business and Economic Statistics

1983-2000

remove

Economic Development and Cultural Change

1952-2001

few pictures in v. 1 and 4

remove v. 6-49

The Economic History Review

1927-2000

few pictures and a graph with color

Leave

International Economic Review

1960-2000

1 foldout

remove

Brookings Papers on Economic Activity

1970-2002

remove

Southern Economic Journal

1933-2002

pictures

Leave

Review of Agricultural Economics

1991-2000

remove

The Journal of the Operational Research Society

1978-2000

remove

Operations Research

1956-2001

remove

Management Science

1954-2001

1 picture

The RAND Journal of Economics

1984-2003

remove

Industrial and Labor Relations Review

1947-2002

2 picture of editor, one in v.31& v.47

Journal of Labor Economics

1983-2001

remove

The Journal of Human Resources

1966-2003

remove

Journal of Organizational Behavior

1988-2000

remove

Economic Geography

1925-2000

pictures

Leave

The Business History Review

1954-2000

pictures

Leave

Journal of Marketing Research

1964-2000

remove

Administrative Science Quarterly

1956-2002

color artwork/pictures on cover of each issue, v. 15-16 have pictures of artwork in articles -flagged

British Journal of Sociology

1950-1998

remove

European Sociological Review

1985-1999

remove

Sociological Perspectives

1983-2002

remove

Sociological Forum

1986-2002

remove

Teaching Sociology

1973-2003

remove

Theory and Society

1974-2002

remove

Sociological Methodology

1969-2003

remove

Sociological Theory

1983-2003

remove

Social Problems

1953-2002

remove

Social Text

1979-1999

pictures

Leave

Social Forces

1925-2002

3 pictures in v.4 and 5

Journal of Marriage and the Family

1964-2000

remove

Gender and Society

1987-2002

remove

Feminist Studies

1972-1998

pictures

Leave

Signs

1975-2002

pictures

Leave

Feminist Review

1979-2000

pictures

Leave

The Future of Children

1991-2005

pictures

Leave

Crime and Justice

1979-2000

remove

Political Theory

1973-2002

remove

Comparative Politics

1968-2000

remove

Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory

1991-1999

remove

The Review of Politics

1939-2002

remove

Political Research Quarterly

1993-2004

remove

International Studies Quarterly

1967-2000

remove

Polity

1968-2000

remove

Canadian Journal of Political Science

1968-2000

remove

British Journal of Political Science

1971-2000

remove

International Affairs

1931-1939, 1944-2000

1992 on there are some pictures

PS: Political Science and Politics

1968-2002

Pictures

Leave

Political Behavior

1979-2002

remove

Human Rights Quarterly

1981-1994

remove

Legislative Studies Quarterly

1964-2002

remove

Law and Contemporary Problems

1933-2000

remove

Public Administration Review

1940-2000

remove

Mershon International Studies Review

1976-2000

remove

International Migration Review

1966-2000

remove

Transactions of the Grotius Society

1918-1959

v.19-22, 24-27, 35, 37, 41 begins with one portrait

Foreign Policy

1970-2002

pictures 1995 and after

International Security

1976-2001

remove

The Journal of Conflict Resolution

1957-2002

remove

Journal of Peace Research

1964-2002

remove

Title

Years in J-STOR

Years on Shelf

Description

Decision

Diacritics

1971-2000

1971-2003

pictures

leave

Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes

1939-2000

fine arts

Philosophy East and West

1951-2002

1951-2005

remove

Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association

1927-2002

1949-2006

remove

Psychological Inquiry

1990-2000

Online only

not on shelf

The American Journal of Psychology

1887-2002

1887-2005

remove after v.77

Child Development

1930-2000

1930-2005

leave

History of Religions

1961-2002

1962-2005

leave

Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion

1961-2000

1961-2005

remove

Numen

1954-2000

1954-2004

remove

Journal of Religion of Africa

1967-2000

1967-2005

leave

AJS Review

1976-2001

1976-2004, 2001 missing

remove

Modern Judaism

1981-1999

1982-2005

remove

Studia Islamica

1953-2002

1953-1978

leave

Buddhist-Christian Studies

1981-2002

1981-2003

leave

The Harvard Theological Review

1908-2000

1908-2004

leave

The Journal of Religion

1921-2003

1921-2005

remove before 2002

Vigiliae Christianae

1947-2000

online only

not on shelf

Church History

1932-2000

1932-2005

remove before 1997

Journal of Biblical Literature

1890-2002

1944-2005

remove after v.78

Vetus Testamentum

1951-2000

Online only

not on shelf

Near Eastern Archaeology

1998-2002

1998-2003

leave

Novum Testamentum

1956-2000

remote storage

Journal of the American Academy of Religion

1967-1999

1933-2005

remove before v.60 1992

Cultural Critique

1985-2002

1985-2005

leave

Technology and Culture

1959-1998

1959-2005

leave

American Antiquity

1935-2002

1935-2005

leave

American Journal of Archaeology

1897-2000

remote storage

World Archaeology

1969-2002

1969-2005

leave

Historical Journal

1958-2000

1958-2005

remove

Past and Present

1952-2000

1952-2005

remove before 1970

Journal of Interdisciplinary History

1970-2000

1970-2005

few pics in v.17

remove

The History Teacher

1967-2002

1967-2005

leave

History and Theory

1960-2001

1960-2005

remove before v.16

Sixteenth Century Journal

1972-2000

1970-2005

leave

Slavic Review

1961-2004

1945-2005

remove before v.48

Journal of Contemporary History

1966-2002

1966-2005

remove

International Studies Review

1999-2000

too few--leave

English Historical Review

1886-2000

1917-2005

remove

Journal of British Studies

1961-2002

1962-2005

remove

Britannia

1970-2002

1970-1974

leave

French Historical Studies

1958-1999

1958-2005

remove

German Studies Review

1978-2000

1980,1984-2005

remove

Greece & Rome

1931-2000

1976-2004

remove before v.34

Hesperia Supplement

1937-2001

don't see on shelf

Hesperia

1932-2002

1965-2004

leave

Archaeological Reports

1954-2003

1955-2004

leave

Journal of Hellenic Studies

1880-2002

1880-2005

leave

Journal of Roman Studies

1911-2002

1966-2005

leave

Russian Review

1941-2000

1941-2005

remove

Europe-Asia Studies

1993-2002

1993-2005

remove

Oriens

1948-1996

1948-1996

leave

Modern Asian Studies

1967-2000

1967-2005

remove

Welt des Islams

1913-2000

1951-2005

leave

International Journal of Middle East Studies

1970-2000

1970-2003

remove

Journal of Near Eastern Studies

1942-2002

1947-2005

leave

Middle East Report

1988-2000

1973-2004

leave

British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies

1991-2002

online only

The Jewish Quarterly Review

1888-2000

1889-1908

remove

Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research

1921-2002

1973-2004

leave

Journal of Palestine Studies

1971-2002

1973-0005

remove before v.26

Pakistan Forum

1970-1973

1966

leave

The China Quarterly

1960-2000

1938-2005

remove

Modern China

1975-2002

1975-2005

remove

Journal of Japanese Studies

1974-2000

1974-2005

remove

The International Journal of African Historical Studies

1972-2002

1962-2004

remove

African Studies Review

1970-2002

1958-2004

remove

African Issues

2000-2002

1999, 2001-2002

too few--leave

The Journal of African History

1960-2000

1960-2004

leave

The Journal of Modern African Studies

1963-2000

1963-2005

remove

African Affairs

1944-1999

1901?-2005

remove

History in Africa

1974-2002

1974-2005

remove

Canadian Journal of African Studies

1967-2000

1967-2004

remove

Journal of Southern African Studies

1974-2002

1974-2005

remove

American Indian Quarterly

1974-2000

1974-2005

remove

Wicazo Sa Review

1985-2002

Online only

not on shelf

Journal of the Early Republic

1981-2002

1988-2005

remove

Phylon

1940-1956, 1960-1992

1943-1987,1987

remove

Phylon Quarterly

1957-1959

see above

Jim Latchney

Cataloging & Reference Librarian

Cataloging and Metadata Services

Michigan State University Libraries

100 Library

East Lansing, MI 48824-1048

(517) 432-6123 x317

(517) 353-8969 (fax)

"...the modern cataloger will one day be a software-enabled specialist who can gather, subset, normalize, and enrich piles of records for a specific audience or purpose."--Roy Tennant, Library Journal, Apr. 15, 2006

-----Original Message-----
From: SERIALST: Serials in Libraries Discussion Forum [mailto:SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU] On Behalf Of Mykie Howard
Sent: Friday, February 16, 2007 11:39 AM
To: SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU
Subject: Re: [SERIALST] JSTOR print backfiles

Jim,

Could you copy the text from the .doc file and paste it into an e-mail to

the whole list.  I'd be interested in seeing it too.

Thanks!

Mykie

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Mykie Howard

Serials Librarian

Morehead State University

Camden-Carroll Library

150 University Dr.

Morehead, KY  40351

my.howard@moreheadstate.edu

ph:606-783-5116

fax:606-783-5037

-----Original Message-----

From: SERIALST: Serials in Libraries Discussion Forum

[mailto:SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU] On Behalf Of Fallon, Judith L.

Sent: Friday, February 16, 2007 11:25 AM

To: SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU

Subject: Re: [SERIALST] JSTOR print backfiles

I would be interested in this list also.

jf@wpi.edu

Judith Fallon

Gordon Library

WPI

100 Institute Road

Worcester, MA 01609

-----Original Message-----

From: SERIALST: Serials in Libraries Discussion Forum

[mailto:SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU] On Behalf Of Latchney, Jim

Sent: Friday, February 16, 2007 9:57 AM

To: SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU

Subject: Re: [SERIALST] JSTOR print backfiles

Our library went through a similar procedure. Our former Assistant Director

for Access and Preservation went through that list of titles and identified

volumes from those titles with plates, maps, etc. that either were not

digitized well in JSTOR or because they had particularly unique images,

etc.,

the print volume was kept. I have a .doc list of those volumes that were

kept

if anyone is interested.

Jim Latchney

Cataloging & Reference Librarian

Cataloging and Metadata Services

Michigan State University Libraries

100 Library

East Lansing, MI 48824-1048

(517) 432-6123 x317

(517) 353-8969 (fax)

"...the modern cataloger will one day be a software-enabled specialist who

can gather, subset, normalize, and enrich piles of records for a specific

audience or purpose."--Roy Tennant, Library Journal, Apr. 15,

2006

-----Original Message-----

From: SERIALST: Serials in Libraries Discussion Forum

[mailto:SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU] On Behalf Of Tian Zhang

Sent: Thursday, February 15, 2007 9:39 AM

To: SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU

Subject: Re: [SERIALST] JSTOR print backfiles

Last year, I attended the NASIG Annual Conference. At the meeting, a

representative from Jstor gave an impressive presentation about Jstor

project. According to the presentation, the information I got is that Jstor

has very good plans of digitizing all the issues of the titles in its list.

From that time on, I realized there is no reason for our library to continue

keeping the bind volumes if they are on Jstor. And we stopped binding any

more volumes of Jstor titles. All the current issues (about 5 years) will be

kept in shelves until they are in Jstor.

We did not ask around whether any libraries will need the bind volumes

assuming academic libraries all subscribe Jstor. But if the foreign country

libraries still accept the bind volumes, please let me know, and we are

willing to ship to them.

The same situation is with our microfilms and microfiches of Jstor

titles.

Tian X. Zhang

Head of Serials Department

St. John's University Library

8000 Utopia Parkway

Queens, NY 11439

Tel. 718 990-5082

Fax 718 990-5938

-----Original Message-----

From: SERIALST: Serials in Libraries Discussion Forum

[mailto:SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU] On Behalf Of Mykie Howard

Sent: Thursday, February 15, 2007 9:03 AM

To: SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU

Subject: Re: [SERIALST] JSTOR print backfiles

How did you find the library in the Middle East, and does anyone know of any

other libraries currently willing to pay shipping for free JSTOR titles?

Thanks!

Mykie

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Mykie Howard

Serials Librarian

Morehead State University

Camden-Carroll Library

150 University Dr.

Morehead, KY  40351

my.howard@moreheadstate.edu

ph:606-783-5116

fax:606-783-5037

-----Original Message-----

From: SERIALST: Serials in Libraries Discussion Forum

[mailto:SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU] On Behalf Of SUSAN BEIDLER

Sent: Wednesday, February 14, 2007 3:10 PM

To: SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU

Subject: Re: [SERIALST] JSTOR print backfiles

Julie,

Lycoming College has withdrawn our print volumes that are included in JSTOR.

Each spring we pull the volumes that have been added to JSTOR, too.

We are a small liberal arts college with no graduate programs.  We were

early

enough in the process that we were able to sell many of them, and another

large group of the volumes went to a library in the Middle East that was

willing and able to pay for shipping.

Hope this helps in your study.  If you have further questions, feel free to

get back to me. Sue Beidler Head of Collection Management

Sue Beidler

Snowden Library

Lycoming College

700 College Place

Williamsport PA 17701

phone: 570-321-4084

fax:      570 321-4090

email: beidler@lycoming.edu

>>> Julie Andel <jandel@MAILER.FSU.EDU> 2/14/2007 12:38 PM >>>

Hello,

I am currently working as a graduate assistant for Millie Jackson, Head of

Collection Development at Florida State University, and I am researching

information about what other libraries are doing with their JSTOR print

collections.

Thank you for any information you can provide.

Julie Andel

Graduate Assistant

Collection Development

Florida State University Libraries

850-645-2709

jandel@mailer.fsu.edu