Re: Backing up floppies - a survey (fwd) Toni Ledgerwood 26 May 1997 22:43 UTC
Our Serials Cataloguer passed this message on to me for reply because as Audio Visual Cataloguer, I deal mostly with software. We are also very interested in the discontinuation of backing up floppies and would be most grateful if you could post your conclusions to the list. > The UCSD Libraries are convening a task group to explore the > possibility of discontinuing the production of backup copies > of data on floppy discs that accompany books and journals. > Our current practice is to back up all accompanying > floppies, circulate the backup copy and archive the master > in our Systems Dept. Before we sit down to discuss > discontinuing this practice I'd like to get some answers to > the following questions: > > 1) Have others among you implemented such a policy and, if > so, are you satisfied with the results? Please describe. 1) We have adopted an identical policy. On the suface, the results seem satisfactory. If a disk is damaged or lost, we always have the original to replace it -- BUT, the staff time and the cost of buying blank disks for all items that have floppies I am sure would out strip the cost of buying replacements for the odd thing that needs it. > 2) If you answered yes to the first question, have you had > to acquire replacement copies of floppies that accompany > books or journal issues in the aftermarket. > > a) If yes, please cite the sources you've found most > useful. > b) If acquiring floppies in the aftermarket has been > problematic, please describe. 2) No. > 3) Regardless of whether you maintain backup copies or not, > do you have a policy in place to "Refresh" your discs > periodically to prevent corruption as they age? If so, > please describe. 3) We have no policy to "refresh" disks periodically. This would again add to costs. I am sure that it would be more economical to replace items that need replacing. Most libraries do not keep back-ups of any other materials - many of which are just as unstable as the floppy disk. > Thanks for taking the time to respond to these questions. > Please respond to me privately as well as to the listserv, > as I'm under time constraints to gather this information > quickly. > > From: David_Fisher@UCSDLIBRARY.UCSD.EDU > > "Because of the workload and processing issues surrounding > making backup copies of commercial software/data purchased > for library collections (usually accompanying a book or > serial), I would like to convene an Ad Hoc task group to > explore the possibility of doing away with this task. The > group will be charged to prepare a recommendation ... > > "The current process is that Catalog Dept. staff make backup > copies of floppy disks, which are then sent with the > materials to their respective library collections. The > original software then goes to ... storage. > > ...we question whether the activity should be done at all. > How often do we go to our backups? What are the risks if we > abandon them? We are also concerned...that we need to have > a "refresh" system in place, as the data on floppy disks can > become corrupt after about five years. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Toni Ledgerwood Audio Visual Cataloguer Southern Cross University Phone: (066) 203 726 PO Box 157 Fax: (066) 220 093 Lismore NSW 2480 email: tledgerw@scu.edu.au Australia http://wwwlib.scu.edu.au ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ "Don't have anything witty to put on the bottom of my e-mail" ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^