I read the pulp after I read the initial comic strips (the big yellow book of reprints), but it’s been nearly 40 years.  I found a 60’s reprint in a used bookstore, along with my first Doctor Who books. :-)  I also read the sequels that were written in the early 80’s, around the time they came out (I read Mordred before I read the original).  If I remember correctly, in the sequels to the pulp that were released in the early 80’s, the Han became aliens.  Most of my ‘for fun’ reading these days consists of “pulps”, I really should take Armageddon 2419 off the shelf and re-read it.  I’m not sure I’d bother reading the sequels, with the possible exception of Mordred (which I don’t believe I own, I read a copy from the library).

I think I finally saw the Buck Rogers serial around 2005, when we bought it on DVD, I’m a big Serial fan, and would have likely enjoyed it, *IF* it wasn’t “Buck Rogers”.

I think “Buck Rogers” is sort of like “The Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy”, in that there is a specific version I consider to be “best”.  For Hitchhikers, that version is the Radio Show.  For Buck Rogers, it’s the original comic strip.

Flash Gordon has done well, in that it’s had several incarnations I enjoy (including the whacked out 6 novel version from the early 80’s that really has nothing to do with Flash Gordon, other than the three main characters).  This thread has made me realize that it’s probably best my wife and I never finished the BSG reboot, we stalled out midway through the 3rd Season.  We were watching it on DVD, and real life got in the way.  We tried to get back to it, and failed.

Zane





On Aug 27, 2020, at 7:39 PM, xxxxxx@gmail.com wrote:


That's where I learned my Buck Rogers and by this standard, as pulpy as it was in ways, the TV series was a big letdown. This story was one of America dominated by 'Hans' (aka the Chinese... and that was quite a few decades back!) who had impervious airships, impervious cities, and disintegrators for offense and point defense. 

Meanwhile, all that the successors to a smashed and depopulated America had left were a bunch of regional tribes (Susquehannas, Delawares, etc) that fought with one another and stayed away from the Han cities. 

Rogers arrives, via a non-space time trip (cold sleep of a sort still applies), and knows a bit about 20th century conflict and starts working to help the tribes get together and find ways to engage the Hans despite their technological superiority. 

It's a bit like a 2nd American Revolution story if you really want to think of it in such a way. 

Warning: Hans are a bit of a nasty depiction of what are obviously future Chinese. Pulp works that this was emulating often made the 'evil oriental' a staple so this is in that vein. But the story as a revolution by pulling together low-tech tribes and getting them up to where they could take on super-science baddies was fun when I was younger. 

When I saw the TV series.... let's just say Deering was much more dangerous in the books....